The Biggest Mistakes Business Owners Make When Selling (And How to Avoid Them)
After years—sometimes decades—of building a business, the last thing you want is to leave money on the table when selling. Yet, many business owners unknowingly make costly mistakes that can lower their valuation, scare away buyers, or even kill a deal entirely. Most sellers don’t get a second chance to sell their business—so getting it right the first time is critical.
In this guide, we’ll break down the biggest mistakes business owners make when selling—and how to avoid them.
- Not Preparing Financials Properly
Why This Is a Costly Mistake
Serious buyers don’t just look at revenue—they dig into profitability, margins, trends, and financial hygiene. If your books are disorganized or unclear, buyers will either walk away or devalue your business to compensate for perceived risk. A business’s financials are its backbone—and sloppy records signal deeper operational inefficiencies.
How to Avoid It
Clean Up Your Financial Statements – Ensure at least three years of detailed, accurate financials prepared by an accountant. Buyers want to see profitability trends, revenue consistency, and expense clarity.
Eliminate Owner-Dependent Expenses – Many small businesses mix personal expenses with business expenses. Separating these costs shows buyers the true profitability of the business.
Boost Your Business’s Profitability (EBITDA) – Buyers evaluate businesses based on EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization), which is a way to measure how much profit a business generates before certain expenses. The higher your EBITDA, the higher your business’s valuation. You can improve this by cutting unnecessary costs and increasing efficiency.
Prepare for Due Diligence – Buyers will scrutinize tax filings, contracts, receivables, and payables. Having everything ready in an organized virtual data room makes the sale process smoother and faster.
Forecast Future Earnings – Buyers are not just purchasing past performance—they are buying future potential. Have a realistic, data-backed growth projection ready.
- Overvaluing or Undervaluing the Business
Why This Is a Costly Mistake
Many business owners let emotions cloud their judgment—overpricing their business because they’ve built it from the ground up, or underpricing it out of fear of losing a deal. Both mistakes can cost you millions. Overpricing scares away serious buyers, while underpricing means you leave money on the table that should be yours.
How to Avoid It
Get a Professional Valuation – Work with a business brokerage or valuation expert to assess your business’s worth based on market trends, revenue, industry comps, and financials.
Understand EBITDA Multiples – Businesses in different industries sell for different EBITDA multiples. Knowing your industry’s average helps you price competitively.
Avoid Unrealistic Price Anchoring – Just because a competitor sold for a high price doesn’t mean your business will. Focus on realistic market expectations.
Be Open to Market Feedback – If multiple buyers show interest but hesitate at the price, be willing to reassess. The market ultimately determines what buyers are willing to pay.
Balance Strategic vs. Financial Buyers – Strategic buyers (competitors or industry firms) may pay more due to synergies, while financial buyers (private equity, individual investors) look at raw numbers.
- Waiting Too Long to Sell
Why This Is a Costly Mistake
Many business owners wait until revenues decline, competition rises, or personal burnout sets in before selling. This often results in a lower valuation or fewer interested buyers.
How to Avoid It
Sell When the Business Is Growing – Buyers pay premium prices for businesses with upward momentum, not those in decline.
Recognize the Signs It’s Time to Sell – If your industry is consolidating, competitors are getting acquired, or you’re losing motivation, it may be the right time to sell before value declines.
Plan Your Exit Strategy Early – Even if you’re not ready to sell today, start preparing now. Businesses with well-structured operations, clean financials, and strong management teams sell faster and for higher prices.
Don’t Rely on Gut Feelings—Use Data – Track profit trends, buyer demand, and market conditions to identify the best time to exit.
Be Proactive About Tax Planning – Waiting until the last minute to consider tax implications could result in unnecessary capital gains tax burdens.
- Failing to Plan for a Smooth Transition
Why This Is a Costly Mistake
A business that relies too heavily on the owner is risky for buyers. If they fear that success will disappear once the owner leaves, they’ll either lower their offer or walk away.
How to Avoid It
Train a Second-in-Command – Having a competent general manager or operations leader makes your business more attractive by reducing owner dependence.
Document Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) – Buyers want to step into a well-organized, process-driven business. Having clear SOPs for daily operations, sales, and customer service adds value.
Offer a Transition Period – Sellers who stay on as consultants for a set period post-sale increase buyer confidence and often command higher sale prices.
Secure Key Employees – Buyers worry about key staff leaving after the sale. Offering retention bonuses or contractual agreements can ease these concerns.
- Not Working with the Right Advisor or Broker
Why This Is a Costly Mistake
Many business owners try to sell on their own or hire the wrong broker—resulting in bad deal structures, fewer buyers, and lower valuations.
How to Avoid It
Choose an Experienced Broker – A top-tier broker does more than just list your business—they help structure the deal, market effectively, and maximize buyer competition.
Work with Legal & Financial Experts – In addition to a broker, having an M&A attorney and tax advisor ensures the deal is structured properly and minimizes tax burdens.
Avoid Discount Brokers or Do-It-Yourself Sales – While saving on fees may seem appealing, a poorly managed sale often results in a lower final price and costly mistakes.
Look for Industry-Specific Brokers – A broker with experience in your industry understands market trends, valuation benchmarks, and key buyers.
Final Thoughts: How to Sell the Right Way
Selling your business shouldn’t be a rushed or emotional decision. By avoiding these common mistakes, you’ll be in a position to attract serious buyers, maximize valuation, and close a smooth, profitable deal.
Click here to schedule a Free Business Valuation Consultation Today!
Our Mission – At GBM Capital, we believe that every business sale is more than just a transaction. We honor the owner’s legacy, recognize the dedication behind the business, and ensure a successful transition that benefits both seller and buyer. Connect with us today to discuss your journey!